stories of Machiavellian triumphs at work, part 2 by Alison Green on March 20, 2024 Last week, I asked about Machiavellian things you’ve seen or done at work. Here’s part two of my favorites. (Part one was Monday.) 1. The voicemail Had a sales guy at my first job in the late 90s who used to take ALL his calls and listen to ALL his voicemail on speaker. LOUDLY. We were a small company with a cube farm. This was the days before caller ID. So one day some of us called when we knew he was out and left a voicemail saying something along the lines of “Hi Fergus, I went to my doctor and the rash is all cleared up.” He never listened to his voicemail on speaker again. 2. The switcheroo When I was rather younger, and back in the days when going to the pub on someone’s last day was de rigueur, one colleague refused to go back to the office at two o’clock. “All that’s going to happen is that [senior manager] will say what a great contribution I’ve made and how sorry you all are to lose me, and he doesn’t even know who I am.” The answer, obvious to anyone awash with beer, was to take a random other colleague and put them forward as the leaver, whereupon the farewell went exactly as predicted (ROC even took the leaving gift of a squash racket, and I’m not sure that ever got to its intended recipient). Had we been slightly more sober, we’d have chosen someone who wasn’t himself scheduled to leave a couple of weeks later, but as he said on his own leaving day “What can they do to me?” The answer was nothing, and in fact the same senior manager trotted out the same platitudes to the same departing worker as he had a fortnight earlier, with never an eyelid batted on either side. 3. The gentle push I was once hired at the same time as another coworker, but for the lower version of the role while she was in the higher version. She then proceeded to spend every day complaining about the job, so I would always tell her she was so right, she deserved better than that job, they didn’t appreciate her, she should follow her bliss, etc. I think it only took a couple of months before she was applying elsewhere, and I agreed that she totally didn’t need to give this place any warning because they didn’t deserve it. Not long after, they were in urgent need of someone to fill that higher version of the role, and why yes I was free and able to fill it, no problem boss. 4. The new policy This is not precisely self serving in a personal way, but I once wired a meeting to prevent a new policy going through that I and others didn’t want. The Division Head wanted the department to support a policy that I and others felt was a bad idea. We didn’t want to openly oppose it. So three of us agreed we would oppose it covertly by amplifying any concerns raised. The meeting started and the policy was presented. One very senior person raised a small issue and so I said ‘I hadn’t thought of it before, but Ida Long has raised an excellent point . . . and then built on that. Another person not in on it agreed and raised another concern and one of my fellow conspirators jumped on that. By the time we were through agreeing with and praising the insightful contributions of others in the group, the proposal was defeated and those who got the credit were the people who had initially voice minor concerns. It worked so well that I used the same technique to get someone selected for a major honor that the CEO thought had been wired for his favorite. 5. The shadow government I accidentally created a shadow government. I had an incompetent boss who was promoted way beyond her experience. She had no clue what she was doing, so she just found excuses not to do work until everyone forgot it was assigned to her. She also had a tendency to just repeat whatever other people said, and to take the side of the most recent person who had spoken to her. I quickly figured out that I could get her to greenlight my ideas by letting her put her name on them. I would prepare a carefully researched and thought-out PowerPoint and share it with her as “hey, here’s a thought that occurred to little old me. I wanted to share it with you to see what you thought — can you dispense your wisdom, O Great Strategic Leader?” She would immediately put her name on it, share it with her boss (she never had her own ideas to share with her boss, so she loved stealing my ideas), then would graciously “allow” me to lead the initiative. I would pretend to be honored, then do her job for her and get the policies I wanted. As long as I always framed it as Seeking Her Guidance and “Gosh, I’d love to do this, thanks!”, she would give me free rein. Within a year, I was doing 80% of her job and functionally running the entire department, making all strategic decisions and setting almost all of the policies. I don’t think she ever figured it out. 6. The hotel booking My former manager has a story of being a relatively junior woman with a male boss, and in the way that often happens, she got asked to do a lot of admin things that weren’t supposed to be part of her job and that her male peers weren’t asked to do. On one occasion, she was asked to book a hotel for her boss. Which she did, uncomplainingly. She found him a hotel very close to the relevant venue… but it was the kind of hotel that’s more usually booked by the hour than for the night. Her boss never asked her to do admin tasks again. 7. The fish cart A colleague claimed to be so overworked his department head hired a full time temp to do his job so he could focus on his special projects. Turns out he wasn’t doing any work except for himself. He started his own business as a consultant while collecting a salary. A client of ours ran into him at the beach where he was selling fish from a food cart (another bizarre side hustle I presume) during a work day, he was found out and fired. Last I heard he was running for mayor in his home town. 8. The security passes I had a government job where my team operated as consultants – technically we had a place in our main office, but in reality we were supposed to be out in the ministries most of the time. So our manager decided we didn’t need security passes to the main office, since we were never going to be there. This policy was apparently fixed, immutable, never ever ever going to change. Except of course we were there fairly often – for team meetings, for days when our clients were unavailable, days when we had no clients, and so on. The receptionist could let us in easily enough, but we also needed security cards to get back out. A lot of people handled this by leaving with someone else, or asking someone who sat near the door to open it for them. But I decided it would be rude to interrupt people’s work just because they happened to be sitting near the door. So – I called my manager instead. Every time. “Hi Fergus, I’m going for lunch now, can you let me out? Heading off to a client meeting for an hour, can you let me out? Leaving for the day, bye! Oh, can you come and let me out? Thanks so much!” It took two days to reverse the the policy and get everyone their passcards. 9. The long lunch My manager hates making decisions, so they often ask me what they should get for lunch. They’re also a bit of a micromanager, and constantly change my priorities minute-to-minute, so I start on a dozen things and finish none of them. On days when they’re really in my hair, I usually suggest a beloved local restaurant known for their huge portions and slow service. It takes my manager out-of-office for about an hour and a half while eating, and after they return, they usually have a “training webinar” that requires a closed door and lots of focus – which is, in fact, a nap on their office couch to sleep off the food coma. It doesn’t work every time, but when it works, it works! 10. The compensation study A few years back, my company was doing a compensation study. For years, there had been requests from staff that the company release salary band information, and the company had finally promised to share salary bands for staff once the study was done. Well, the study was completed and suddenly the company reversed its decision and said they wouldn’t be sharing the salary bands after all. Fine. A colleague and I put together a google spreadsheet with salary info (current salary, starting salary, years worked, demographic info, etc.) and shared it with our closer colleagues so those who were interested could share their salaries (no pressure). When my boss found out and said he felt obligated to inform HR, we released it on the all-staff slack channel. We didn’t make any friends in HR that day, and ultimately only about 10% of staff chose to fill it out. But a few weeks later, the company released the salary bands, and I sent a (public) sugary sweet thank you to our HR team for supporting pay equity. You may also like:was my interviewer in the wrong ... or was I?what's up with people responding to emails with a phone call?coworker keeps making minor corrections to my work, using info from recruiters to negotiate salary, and more { 151 comments }
WellRed* March 20, 2024 at 2:12 pm It took me a minute but OMG on the first one! Ok, going back to read the rest! Reply ↓
H.C.* March 20, 2024 at 4:14 pm If I can be sure that I won’t be ID’d on the voicemail, I would’ve been much less subtle about it: “Hey there, calling because my doctor confirmed the STI diagnosis, you might wanna get a checkup too.” Reply ↓
Nervousmelon* March 20, 2024 at 5:52 pm yeah it’s the kind of thing you need a good friend to do for you (aka one that doesn’t work there) Reply ↓
Abundant Shrimp* March 20, 2024 at 5:38 pm #1 is my hero. I started working in the US in the 90s and have worked with *so many* Ferguses, and with *so many* people who wanted to do something like that to our office Ferguses, but nobody has the courage or the creativity to think of a VM that would’ve been concise and to the point. Bravo. Reply ↓
Generic Name* March 20, 2024 at 6:55 pm I really wish I or a coworker had thought of this when I worked in a small office for a Fergus. Reply ↓
Warrior Princess Xena* March 20, 2024 at 2:13 pm #6 is my hero. She sure gave him what he asked for! Reply ↓
Snarkus Aurelius* March 20, 2024 at 2:17 pm #6> at my first job, I was a female in a male dominated industry. I was not, have never been, and never will be an admin. (You don’t want me as one anyway! I’m very bad at it.) I kept getting asked to make coffee for this one very important meeting. I don’t drink coffee. Never have. Don’t know how to operate any machine. For real! It took only two times for me to screw up coffee up, and no one ever asked me to do it again. A proper admin did it! Finally! Reply ↓
Magenta Sky* March 20, 2024 at 2:25 pm I only had to describe how I’d make the coffee (“The bucket you put the coffee grounds in are that size for a reason – you fill it up level to the top, right?”) and I was told I didn’t have to make coffee after all. (Not female, we kept a pot for customers, which went over well. Because the folks who made the coffee knew how to.) Reply ↓
LoraC* March 20, 2024 at 6:06 pm I just poured water back in. IDK, do you have to change out the grounds or something? I reuse teabags so coffee should be fine too. Reply ↓
Inkognyto* March 20, 2024 at 6:25 pm I like coffee, I didn’t mind making it after the pot was empty, but most of my co-workers never let me make it after I do. I like it WAY stronger than most. Why because the pre-ground junk that most of our vendors had tasted like tea it was so weak. I used to do at least a 1/2 size more, prefer a double the bag/amount to get it strong. I’m a fresh ground person and anything pre-ground is never strong enough in ‘recommended’ amounts. The manager also liked it this strong, we made it in the decaf pot. One there was no decaf purchased (it was stopped because the stuff sat never used), and no one ever used the pot. Others learned fast. Then the new person started and someone else was assigned to give them a tour and the office basics. Coffee was skipped. I came in later but my mgr had made the strong coffee, and he was a person who liked decaffeinated coffee and poured a cup. I guess later he told the mgr there was something wrong with the decaf. she couldn’t stop laughing when telling me this. She’s like it was his 2nd day and he was very animated and talked fast. I was concerned about medical reasons for it, and she said no. A month later he was a convert to the ‘Decaf’ club, and a very productive worker. Reply ↓
Looper* March 20, 2024 at 2:20 pm #5 didn’t note whether they got the salary or title of their boss, 80% of whose work they were doing. So kinda feels like maybe the Boss is the Machiavellian one here lol Reply ↓
Dorothy Zpornak* March 20, 2024 at 2:23 pm Came here to say exactly this. I feel like there should be another letter somewhere from a manager gleefully recounting how she bamboozled her underling into doing her entire job while she takes all the credit, status, and financial benefits, buwahahahaha. Reply ↓
ferrina* March 20, 2024 at 3:31 pm I was #5. There was a part 2 to the story that has the karmatic triumph you’re looking for. I re-built my resume using all the accomplishments I had done for my boss. My industry is such that it was very clear that I was doing my boss’s job without the title, and another company quickly hired me. I got the same title as that boss, making an extra $15-$20k more than that boss. When I left, it became obvious that I had been doing her job. Half the company already knew what was going on, and the other half quickly figured it out when suddenly my ex-boss couldn’t do even basic tasks. She stopped responding to email and went into corporate hiding, her department had 80% turnover, and within three years Ex-Boss, her boss, and her boss’s boss were all forced out. Reply ↓
House On The Rock* March 20, 2024 at 3:41 pm This is indeed deeply satisfying. Your story was very reminiscent of my last job where I and a couple other middle managers slowly chipped away at almost all of our incompetent director’s responsibilities and took them on (and did them better without his interference). Sometimes it rankled, but it also meant that when he finally ran afoul of other higher-ups in a political brouhaha, it was quite clear that he wasn’t doing anything and was shuffled out in a reorg. Meanwhile the other middle managers and I parlayed our experience into better, more rewarding, better paying jobs. Reply ↓
Lucia Pacciola* March 20, 2024 at 4:02 pm I dunno. That sounds like pretty standard ambition and work ethic to me: Take on more work, take credit for it, get a promotion and a raise as a result. And that second paragraph kinda rubs me the wrong way. Unless your Machiavellian scheme was to screw over your boss and nuke the department, *and they had it coming*, why would you celebrate this? Reply ↓
WellRed* March 20, 2024 at 4:23 pm OP didn’t get credit, she did the work and the boss took the credit. The only person here doing any screwing over was the boss who eventually screwed herself. Reply ↓
Lucia Pacciola* March 20, 2024 at 5:14 pm I mean, they did put legitimate work experience on their resume, and used it to get a new job with a higher title and salary. They didn’t take credit in their own org, but a lot of times that’s the best play – still not Machiavellian, though. I admit I’m enjoying the retcons. Reply ↓
Resident Catholicville, U.S.A.* March 20, 2024 at 4:40 pm Once the OP was out the door, it was on the boss and the department to sink or swim. Unfortunately, the department sank. Every single job I’ve left, I’ve left knowing I did everything I could to set it up for success- and if it failed after I leave, it was on them. It sounds like the OP contributed greatly to the success of the department *while they were there* and if the rest didn’t keep that up after OP left? That’s on them. Reply ↓
Lucia Pacciola* March 20, 2024 at 5:16 pm That’s totally on them, I agree. It’s not very Machiavellian, though. It’s not like LW schemed behind their back to set them up for failure. LW just did their job really well, and moved on to a better opportunity on the strength of that work. Reply ↓
Seeking Second Childhood* March 20, 2024 at 6:54 pm To be fair, the second half you’re complaining about wasn’t in the original answer… it was added after OP was asked what happened next. Reply ↓
Abundant Shrimp* March 20, 2024 at 5:41 pm Boss was happy as a clam with OP doing her work and her collecting the paycheck for the work OP was doing. She thought it was going to last forever and all of a sudden, surprise! It ended. Well worth celebrating to me. Reply ↓
KB* March 20, 2024 at 8:09 pm Oh, thank goodness you added this addendum! What I was hoping for is far more Machiavellian, though…. “A month before I knew I was leaving that role, I proposed the worst possible idea I could think of. I spent a few weeks implementing the idea that would have devastating impact for months to come. Eventually boss was let go and just yesterday I discovered that they are now going to jail for some kind of bitcoin scheme they started just after my old workplace fired them.” Reply ↓
I'm just here for the cats!* March 20, 2024 at 2:24 pm my thought exactly. why do the work without the pay Reply ↓
Antilles* March 20, 2024 at 2:31 pm The Boss got the salary of a manager, the credit for the good ideas, the halo effect from the group’s success, all while passing off 80% of the work. There’s certainly a story of Machiavellian triumph here, it’s just not the one that OP#5 thinks it is. Reply ↓
Dont ask about StateFarm* March 20, 2024 at 2:41 pm Exactly! Not only did the boss pass on 80% of the work (assumingly without increased pay or benefits), she convinced #5 to be happy about it! Reply ↓
ferrina* March 20, 2024 at 3:27 pm I was #5. And I certainly wasn’t happy- it was more an act of self-preservation. The boss wasn’t clever enough to have a devious underlying scheme. And even if she had been trying to do that, it backfired spectacularly- I left less than 2 years after she took over, and suddenly she was not producing anything. Half the company already knew I was doing her job, and the other half caught on really quickly after I left. Reply ↓
Lacey* March 20, 2024 at 3:12 pm Yes, the boss in #5 sounds an awful lot like a manager in the company I work for. I couldn’t help wondering which of my coworkers thinks they’re pulling a fast one by letting her take credit for all their hard work! Reply ↓
ferrina* March 20, 2024 at 3:21 pm The trick is to have an exit plan. The karma is self-enacting. Reply ↓
ferrina* March 20, 2024 at 3:20 pm I was #5. And it actually worked out beautifully…. I did this song and dance for about a year and a half. Then updated my resume with all my accomplishments, most of which were things known in my industry for being done by higher levels. I got a MUCH better job at a MUCH better company. When I left, my boss tried to counter-offer me. I laughed and politely told her not to waste her time- my new role was the same titles as hers, and at a higher payband than hers (by about $15-$20k). Her expression was priceless. Once I left the department fell apart. They had 80% turnover in the first year. The negligent boss totally vanished (her own staff had no idea where she was). The company had to rebuild the department from the ground up. Coincidentally, the grandboss who had selected my incompetent boss was unceremoniously let go about a year after I left (maybe something to do with drastically dwindling revenue and high turnover?). A couple years after that, the CEO who had created a culture of “expertise isn’t that important” was forced out as well. Meanwhile, I am very happy and thriving at my new job. Reply ↓
tb3* March 20, 2024 at 3:41 pm Right? Did you get the pay or the title? How is this a good thing that you are leading the company without any of the compensation for that? Reply ↓
Mellor* March 20, 2024 at 3:49 pm This was what I thought too! Alison, I think #5 would benefit from some additional context the OP has provided in this thread. Reply ↓
Dark Macadamia* March 20, 2024 at 3:49 pm Yep… I can understand if you’re passionate about the work you might feel like the outcome is what matters and you’re just glad things went how you wanted, but it’s not self-serving to basically donate your labor to the company so they/your boss can benefit. Reply ↓
Hmm* March 20, 2024 at 2:20 pm Honest question for #5, no snark intended- is that… good? I was expecting the story to end with you getting her title and a pay raise but where it ends it essentially just sounds like you doing her entire job for her with no credit or salary benefits. I feel like itʻs less “she never noticed” and more “she had a ridiculously good thing going with you doing her work and she gets to keep her job” Reply ↓
Hiring Mgr* March 20, 2024 at 3:17 pm Yeah i was wondering who’s the Machiavellian one here – OP or the boss Reply ↓
anonymous anteater* March 20, 2024 at 3:30 pm they left a comment on the thread right above this one! Reply ↓
Lucia Pacciola* March 20, 2024 at 4:03 pm They left a retcon on the thread right above this one. Reply ↓
HipsandMakers* March 20, 2024 at 5:55 pm I find it fascinating that someone can have apparently very strong feelings about the precise semantics of “Machiavellian” and then turn around and be so semantically loose with “retcon”. Reply ↓
sparkle emoji* March 20, 2024 at 8:15 pm Agreed, some of the Machiavellian definition distinctions felt like word nitpicking. Reply ↓
Pickle Shoes* March 20, 2024 at 6:18 pm Even if it’s not an accurate word choice, it fits better than Machiavellian. The story we started with had the LW proudly sharing them being taken advantage of for over a year while thinking their boss never did figure it out. The addition in the comments seems odd, at the very least, since it’s the part of the story that’s actually relevant and paints a very different setup. Reply ↓
HipsandMakers* March 20, 2024 at 6:26 pm Here’s that poster saying pretty much exactly what she said today in the comments of the original post. Link to follow. Reply ↓
HipsandMakers* March 20, 2024 at 6:26 pm https://www.askamanager.org/2024/03/whats-the-most-machiavellian-thing-youve-seen-or-done-at-work-2.html#comment-4641219
Seeking Second Childhood* March 20, 2024 at 7:00 pm Well, she did work she wanted to do, others in the company knew she was doing her boss’s worķ, and she parlayed it into a promotion with extremely good pay within 2 years. Close enough for me. Reply ↓
Peanut Hamper* March 20, 2024 at 9:04 pm I think the thing about something being Machiavellian is that it doesn’t look very Machiavellian until the very end. A Machiavellian scheme doesn’t mean that you are there twirling your mustache from the very beginning in an obvious way. This is close enough for me, as well. It’s quite brilliant, actually.
brjeau* March 20, 2024 at 3:28 pm They responded to the comment above this one (from Looper) with more details about the aftermath, looks like it did pay off! Reply ↓
Hmm* March 20, 2024 at 3:54 pm Thatʻs good that it worked out. I feel like itʻs still a reeeeally risky long game that will not work out in the workerʻs favor a majority of the time, but good on OP5 for making it work. Reply ↓
Hmm* March 20, 2024 at 3:57 pm I didnʻt mean to say “work” so many times in two sentences, but I guess it works (hah) with the theme of this website. Reply ↓
Heffalump* March 20, 2024 at 2:22 pm #1–was the person who left the VM male- or female-presenting? Reply ↓
I edit everything* March 20, 2024 at 2:24 pm #4: For a minute, I thought the OP had rigged recording devices in the conference room. Then I realized that “wired” means “rigged.” Reply ↓
Strict Extension* March 20, 2024 at 2:36 pm Yeah, I’ve never understood “wired” to have the meaning OP uses here, so I spent a while wondering what the benefit of installing surveillance equipment is on a meeting you are yourself attending. Reply ↓
Artemesia* March 20, 2024 at 2:42 pm That was mine and I am older than the hills — it may be a slang term from my youth — so yes — rigged. Reply ↓
Strict Extension* March 20, 2024 at 3:02 pm After I read the whole thing I figured it out by context, and it has a certain kind of logic. In a physical sense, “wiring” and “rigging” can be synonyms. It was just a new usage to me. Reply ↓
Slow Gin Lizz* March 20, 2024 at 3:18 pm That was a brilliant story, though. Kudos to you. I have been doing something to this effect for our lazy and dishonest coworker who I have no control over and it’s been somewhat enjoyable. I mean, what would be a lot more enjoyable would be if she got fired but that may take a couple more weeks. For now, though, we’ve been pushing back on her nonsense by asking very detailed clarifying questions and then laughing internally when she can’t answer them. So, not quite the same as what you and your colleagues did, but trying to rig the game so that TPTB (who are mostly ineffective, or else this person would have been fired weeks ago) will see how truly incompetent and dishonest she is without actually tell them that I think she is. (Though my boss has certainly told them…here’s hoping she’ll be fired soon.) Reply ↓
The Rafters* March 20, 2024 at 3:34 pm I’m probably as old as you are Artemesia. In my younger working years, “wired” meant you had an “in” with some high up muckety muck, i.e., “wired to the Governor’s office,” “wired to the White House.” Reply ↓
fhqwhgads* March 20, 2024 at 7:42 pm Yeah it puzzled me too when I read the original post. Like, I get it now they meant it metaphorically, but at first it took me a minute, like is that an expression? Reply ↓
AhJustMe* March 20, 2024 at 7:00 pm I came here to ask that; thanks for clarifying. Totally thought the room was actually wired, until I got to the end and it made no sense. Reply ↓
Retail Dalliance* March 20, 2024 at 2:25 pm I feel kind of ignorant but I’m not sure I understand #2 as it is worded. Someone was leaving for good, didn’t want to come back to the office after the pub lunch, and they just…subbed out the person who was leaving for someone who was staying? Reply ↓
Magenta Sky* March 20, 2024 at 2:28 pm Yep. And the boss doing the “we’re sad you’re leaving” speech didn’t notice. And also didn’t notice a few weeks later then the substitute also left. Reply ↓
RabbitRabbit* March 20, 2024 at 2:29 pm Staying for another two weeks only. Two weeks later, that person did return to the office and received the same platitudes/handshake from the same manager without any sign that the manager realized the duplication. Reply ↓
Jzilbeck* March 20, 2024 at 2:33 pm You’re not alone. I read that one like 5 times and still wasn’t sure exactly what happened. Reply ↓
Two Dog Night* March 20, 2024 at 2:49 pm Yup. And then the sub left 2 weeks later, and the manager never noticed that s/he said goodbye to the same person twice. (LW2, it made sense to me, and it’s hilarious!) Reply ↓
ferrina* March 20, 2024 at 3:44 pm I had to read it a couple times, then it clicked and I started laughing out loud. That was amazing! Reply ↓
Ama* March 20, 2024 at 2:56 pm That one was mind boggling to me but I’ve also only ever worked in smallish places where the manager giving the goodbye speech has at most 4-5 direct reports so there’s no way they wouldn’t notice that the wrong person was standing there. Reply ↓
Reality.Bites* March 20, 2024 at 7:12 pm Sometimes the person giving the speech is a grandboss or great-grandboss. Reply ↓
Bitte Meddler* March 20, 2024 at 2:59 pm Leaving Person #1 (LP1) didn’t go back to the office for the formal goodbyes because the Senior Manager doesn’t even know who they are, so all the “We’re so sorry to lose LP1, they’ve been a great contributor and I know you all love them as much as I do,” stuff would be completely meaningless. So the group decided that Someone Who Isn’t Leaving Person #1 (SWILP1) should stand in for LP1. And, yep, the Senior Manager had no idea they weren’t LP1 and gave all the hollow platitudes (plus a squash racquet). BUT… it turns out that SWILP1 had already put in their notice and was leaving the company in two weeks. So, two weeks later, SWILP1 got another send-off full of hollow platitudes from the Senior Manager who, apparently, did not realize that this person was the same one whom he just gave a squash racquet to a couple weeks earlier. No mention of whether or not SWILP#1 got a second squash racquet. Reply ↓
Christmas Carol* March 20, 2024 at 3:52 pm Yes, I’m dying to know about the squash racket too. Reply ↓
Heffalump* March 20, 2024 at 3:23 pm In a way this is the inverse of “the new hire who showed up is not the same person we interviewed.” https://www.askamanager.org/2022/01/the-new-hire-who-showed-up-is-not-the-same-person-we-interviewed.html Reply ↓
Thomas* March 20, 2024 at 7:06 pm It took me three or four reads to realise that the oblivious butt of the joke is the senior manager giving the “we’ll miss you so much” kind of speech. Reply ↓
NeutralJanet* March 20, 2024 at 7:23 pm It’s kind of funny, but I don’t really understand how it’s Machiavellian. No one gained anything from it and it wasn’t a particularly cunning or clever scheme. Reply ↓
Lucia Pacciola* March 20, 2024 at 4:05 pm 1 is passive aggressive nonsense. 2 is a basic prank. 3 and 4 are some proper Machiavellian schemes, though. Reply ↓
goddess21* March 20, 2024 at 5:20 pm ur both good at being uncharitable and aces at misunderstanding ‘passive aggression’ Reply ↓
Peanut Hamper* March 20, 2024 at 8:09 pm #1 is sheer genius, but it is not passive-aggressive. (Having had several family members and bosses who were actually passive-aggressive, I can assure that’s not what passive-aggressive means.) #2 though — I really hope that guy got another squash racket! Reply ↓
Cleopatra, Queen of Denial* March 20, 2024 at 2:27 pm #9 is the kind of boss who could totally be taken out of commission for the rest of the day by an entire family-sized chicken pot pie Reply ↓
Mephyle* March 20, 2024 at 3:22 pm I don’t know which is the best part – managing the boss to gain undisturbed work time, or the “training webinar”. I want to title this one “The Long Lunch and the Training Webinar”. Reply ↓
Magenta Sky* March 20, 2024 at 2:27 pm #8 reminds me of a controller we had who decided we were too loose with the use of the company credit card (and she was right), and came up with an authorization form that had to be countersigned by two of the three higher ups in the office (who were rarely in the office at the same time), or by the owner alone. The third time in an hour and a half I went to the owner to get him to sign off on a $20 part from Amazon, he followed me out of the office, and had a chat with the controller, and the policy was . . . relaxed. Malicious compliance is tasty, with a little salt. Reply ↓
MigraineMonth* March 20, 2024 at 4:00 pm As someone who’s worked in high-security environments, this isn’t even malicious compliance, it’s basic compliance! Regularly letting someone in/out without the proper security clearance/permissions/cards/tokens is a big deal. Though I’m not entirely sure why they put so much security on people exiting; that seems like it could become a safety issue. Reply ↓
Margaret Cavendish* March 20, 2024 at 4:25 pm Oh, definitely – no argument at all with needing passcards to get in! I never did understand why we needed them to get out, rather than having an unlock button or a crash bar, but I knew that wasn’t going to change. I did understand the manager’s logic behind not giving passcards to the consultants – I disagreed with it, but I could see where he was coming from. Probably there was some fee associated with them in the dept budget, and he decided to save a couple of dollars by only giving cards to people who Really Needed Them. All I did was help adjust his perspective on who those people were! Reply ↓
ArtK* March 20, 2024 at 4:29 pm Probably tracking in-and-out movement. I’m sure the building codes require crash bars or the like for exits in an emergency. What grinds my gears is that they didn’t bother to use the electronic logs to see how often these people were using their badges. Thirty seconds with a report and they’d realize that the badges are needed. Reply ↓
Magenta Sky* March 20, 2024 at 6:11 pm This wasn’t a high security environment. And I certainly could have annoyed people other than the owner, and I could have combined the orders doing so. It was, indeed, compliance, but it was, indeed, malicious. Reply ↓
Thomas* March 20, 2024 at 7:14 pm It’s to make it harder for an intruder to leave undetected, possibly with stolen information or property. Yes there’s an emergency exit bar or suchlike, but that will be configured to instantly alert security. Not everywhere thinks it’s worth the trouble, but that’s the idea. Reply ↓
FricketyFrack* March 20, 2024 at 2:31 pm The most Machiavellian thing I’ve ever done at work only resulted in a new microwave for the breakroom. The head of the state department I worked at had an assistant known as “the Dragon Lady” and she decided we could keep using our old fire hazard of a microwave that routinely turned off because it got too hot. I sent an email to all staff saying I would buy a new one because it was A FIRE HAZARD, but if anyone would like to contribute to the cause, that would be nice (because I was one of the lowest paid employees). Within a couple of hours, the department head had emailed saying that it was very nice of me to offer, but he thought our budget could probably accommodate the cost of a new microwave. Anyway, great success, but I’m realizing I can aim bigger. I SHOULD aim bigger. Next stop, ice cream machine! Reply ↓
Abogado Avocado* March 20, 2024 at 3:32 pm And after that, may I suggest you set your sights on a commercial Sonic-ice-style ice maker? I know you can do it! Reply ↓
FricketyFrack* March 20, 2024 at 3:40 pm Ugh, I should. We have a couple of ice makers but it’s just stupid regular ice. Although I’ve actually heard rumors that when we move to our new building, we’re getting new ones anyway. Seriously though, my 5 person department has a microwave, toaster, Dash pancake maker, air fryer, Keurig Duo, and electric kettle. Please god, no more appliances. Reply ↓
CrabbyPatty* March 20, 2024 at 5:29 pm Our Sonic-ice (pellet ice) maker in the work breakroom died about five weeks ago. A new one is approved but still hasn’t manifested. My theory is that they are perpetrating a scheme on us; We are going to get stupid regular ice, but if they delay long enough, us lukewarm beverage drinkers will be so pathetically grateful for ANY ICE AT ALL that we won’t quibble over cubes… Reply ↓
New Mom (of 1 7/9)* March 20, 2024 at 10:16 pm Well, of course she wanted to keep it. Dragons like fire, right? Reply ↓
Forrest Rhodes* March 20, 2024 at 3:00 pm Agreed. I think Machiavelli himself would be proud of that one. Reply ↓
Artemesia* March 20, 2024 at 2:53 pm Rigged — wired means the same thing but has apparently fallen into desuetude — or perhaps it was a regional usage — I grew up in Seattle and we invented a lot of slang terms there. Reply ↓
NotAN00b* March 20, 2024 at 2:55 pm Ah! I see the response now. It wasn’t showing in the thread when I first posted. Reply ↓
I've Got The Shrimp* March 20, 2024 at 8:50 pm I was coming to ask the same thing, thank you! Reply ↓
Anat* March 20, 2024 at 2:49 pm #4 — Now that is a transferable life skill! I’m so impressed, and I’ll keep the story in my back pocket in case it ever comes in handy. Reply ↓
Snoozing not schmoozing* March 20, 2024 at 2:50 pm #4 and #5 sound like standard, everyday office maneuvers to work around less-than-perfect managers. Reply ↓
Awkwardness* March 20, 2024 at 4:26 pm In order to pull off #4, you really need to coordinate and be on the same page among several colleagues. Between those having different opinions, those not wanting to speak up and those with their own loyalties, this is not possible most of the time. I applaud #4 even more! Reply ↓
Snoozing not schmoozing* March 20, 2024 at 5:28 pm I guess my workplace was so messed up, it was common to have the staff plotting like that at any given time, and frequently succeeding. The best scheme was when a handful of us got the president/CEO fired. Reply ↓
Miss Muffett* March 20, 2024 at 2:56 pm #5 – weaponized competence followed directly by #6 – weaponized incompetence. Genius! Reply ↓
Richard Hershberger* March 20, 2024 at 3:15 pm I get pushback around here whenever I advocate for weaponized incompetence. It is only appropriate for stuff that is not actually your job, but with that proviso I consider it perfectly cromulent for BS stuff. Reply ↓
House On The Rock* March 20, 2024 at 3:48 pm It’s a really important thing to be able to do if you are someone who naturally has things foisted on you due to gender, race, age, or simply having done it once before. Sometimes people do it to get out of work they should, but not always! Reply ↓
She of Many Hats* March 20, 2024 at 4:45 pm My on-site IT person has left the company and they’re not filling the opening. The rest of the IT Helpdesk is located in a different state. As the office admin, I’m clinging to my IT ineptitude unless they give me a noticeable pay raise because I would become the CEO’s onsite Help Desk otherwise. Reply ↓
All het up about it* March 20, 2024 at 2:58 pm All amazing, but #8 just really sings in my book! Reply ↓
Frieda* March 20, 2024 at 5:42 pm I did a paler version of that when IT kept fucking up everyone’s entry fob. Assign me a classroom in a building that I can’t get into? I will call you, every time, and require someone to walk from their building to the one I’m trying to get into to let me in. Because it’s an often-used building I started going early while the prior classes were still in session so that no students were coming in or out, to retain the thinnest veneer of plausible deniability about the urgency of the situation. Fixed it pretty quickly, they did. Reply ↓
TeenieBopper* March 20, 2024 at 3:12 pm That salary band story. Hell yeah. Not a union organizing success story, but it’s pretty close. Reply ↓
McFizzle* March 20, 2024 at 3:12 pm #6 deserves the highest honors. Brilliantly done! The gender aspects on both sides has me literally cackling. Brava! Reply ↓
Jellyfish Catcher* March 20, 2024 at 3:34 pm Hey Alison – we need Machiavelli Day at least every 6 months – or (fiscal) quarters, even better ! It’s like updates but all entires are So Satisfying…. and have many Good Ideas. Reply ↓
Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain* March 20, 2024 at 3:49 pm I always feel like the consultant-side-hustle-fish-cart-mayor-guys end up working way harder at their multiple shenanigans than they would if they just did one job moderately poorly for as long as they can. I salute the people who can take an hour-and-a-half lunch, then have a “training webinar” the rest of the day. Reply ↓
WellRed* March 20, 2024 at 4:31 pm I totally agree! Why would he want to sell fish from a cart at the risk of his real job? Reply ↓
Seeking Second Childhood* March 20, 2024 at 7:12 pm Until I thought about all the other details, I wondered if he was just pitching in to help a friend or family member with their truck. But everything else adds up to something weirder. Reply ↓
Peanut Hamper* March 20, 2024 at 8:58 pm He’s obviously one of these “idea guys” who always think they have great ideas which actually aren’t, and he’s just waiting for the rest of the world to catch up to his greatness. In reality, the world has left him in the dust. Reply ↓
Suzie the Doozie* March 20, 2024 at 4:48 pm I used to manage a training system. Most of the items in the system could never be deleted once created; the exception, however, was a group. A group was created to assign training – think “all managers” as a group – and you use this to assign training that is for managers only. Someone kept deleting my groups – which meant the training with no longer be assigned. I was pretty sure it was “Samantha”, a passive aggressive co-worker who was after my job. Always fake nice when management team was around – but always with a not-so-subtle verbal jab. Very few people had the access to delete the groups, but Samantha was one. Since I sat right next to her, I made a fake phone call later in the day when most people were gone. I pretended to talk to the company that created the training system about a new feature that traced EVERY single action in the system. (Things got real quiet at Samantha‘s desk during this “conversation”.) I said “wow, so you can literally see if somebody deletes a group, and who it was, and what time of day it happened, etc..?” After an appropriate silence I said “ok, great! How do I turn this feature on? Oh, it’s already on? Fantastic! How do I see the records of say, who might have deleted a group?” Total silence from Samantha’s cube. After wrapping up my “conversation”, I never had another deleted group. I’m sure that was just a coincidence. Reply ↓
TPS Reporter* March 20, 2024 at 5:50 pm Has anyone watched The Traitors (Australia, UK or US versions)? A lot of these schemers would be great contestants! Reply ↓
Len* March 20, 2024 at 6:10 pm #5: well, unless you were getting paid to run the department, it sounds like you played yourself Reply ↓
linger* March 20, 2024 at 7:09 pm OP5 notes above that after updating her CV to reflect her actual Boss-level accomplishments, she got hired into a similar position to Boss at a higher salary, then watched the department implode in her rear view mirror as Boss, Grandboss, and Greatgrandboss were ousted in turn. [See comments by ferrina.] Reply ↓
Ham* March 20, 2024 at 6:11 pm #5 seems pretty ordinary to me, today I learned this isn’t normal management? Reply ↓
Jellyfish Catcher* March 20, 2024 at 6:35 pm Regarding # 2. Did the stand-in guy get a second squash racket at his genuine retirement? Hope so. Reply ↓
I went to school with only 1 Jennifer* March 20, 2024 at 7:31 pm This is the important question. Reply ↓
Dido* March 20, 2024 at 8:11 pm I think the fire marshal would have a lot to say about #8’s workplace requiring a security card to get out Reply ↓
Expelliarmus* March 20, 2024 at 8:43 pm Badging in and out of a workplace is pretty normal IME. Reply ↓
New Jack Karyn* March 20, 2024 at 8:51 pm Is there an automatic release in an evacuation? It doesn’t sound safe to me, but I’ve never worked in an office like that, so there might be stuff in place that I’d never even think of. Reply ↓