my employee keeps telling me his “expectations” of me

by Alison Green on April 28, 2025

The site is having some server issues today so while we work on those, here’s an older post. This was originally published in 2019. (And hopefully everything will be back to normal shortly.)

A reader writes:

I’m a mid-level college administrator. One of my direct reports is positioning himself to move up in a couple of years (from department member to department head). He would still report to me, but the working relationship would be a little different. I need to work closely with department heads, and it can have a major impact on my work and the organization if that relationship is toxic.

The problem is that he thinks he is a LOT smarter than me. He apparently read something about “managing up” and now he is trying to manage me. He is very, very bad at it. His attempts to manipulate me are clumsy and obvious, but he doesn’t realize that I know what he is doing (because he’s sure that he is much smarter than me). There’s also some sexism going on here (I’m female, and he seems to have problems with that sometimes) and I’m relatively new to the organization, so he doesn’t know me well. Every conversation degenerates into incredibly irritating condescension and smugness on his part. For example, he has said things like:

• “My expectation is that you will give me a hint if you think there may be a change coming up.” Me: No, not happening. I try to squelch rumors, not spread them. And if there is a change coming, your department head will know first.

• “My expectation is that you will change the meeting time.” Me: No, a meeting that involves 27 people and has been scheduled for a month will not be rescheduled just for you.

• About a minor snafu with the bookstore: “I’m sure you understand why you need to have this person fired.” Me: Let’s just talk about how we are going to handle a fairly small problem.

• About a trivial department matter that could easily have been resolved before it even got to me: “I know that you will do the right thing and bring this to the Chief Academic Officer.” (That’s the equivalent of the CEO.) Me: Here’s the solution that I see.

He always ends with a smirk and a slow nod. His body language says that he is certain he has programmed me to respond correctly.

Right now, I just smile, ignore it whenever possible, and get back to the issue at hand. Occasionally I have addressed it head on, when I need to clarify that he will definitely not be getting what he wants this time.

I want to call him on this, because it is getting very tiresome. It also sidetracks the conversation away from the important stuff we need to be discussing. And I don’t enjoy being treated with such disrespect. If he does become the department head, it will be even more important that he have some respect for my intelligence. I’m tempted to give him a book on the topic and tell him he needs to study some more before trying this again. But in calmer moments, I know that level of bluntness (sarcasm, snark, whatever you want to call it) will just embarrass him and put him on the defensive. How can I stop this behavior without doing too much damage to our work relationship? Or do I just have to put up with sentences that start, “My expectation is that you will…” forever?

(A complicating factor is that he’s popular with his colleagues, which is why he will be very seriously considered for the department head position. In academia, that decision is made by the faculty. I could potentially veto their decision, but right now I don’t have enough ammunition to go nuclear. And it would destroy my credibility with the rest of the department. That’s why I would rather figure out how to make this work if I can.)

This guy sounds incredibly obnoxious. And also, if he’s trying to manage you, he’s really bad at it.

“Managing up” doesn’t mean “pretend that you’re your boss’s manager and tell them what to do.” It means working with your boss in a way that will produce the best possible results for both of you and figuring out what is and isn’t within your sphere of control to act upon.

So he’s confused on the concept.

But you’re right that your options are complicated by what sounds like a genuine need to handle him more delicately than you ideally would.

Ideally — in a situation with politics different than this one — you’d just name what he’s doing and tell him to stop. The next time he started in with “my expectation is that you will…” you’d say, “Framing this as ‘your expectations of me’ is coming across really strangely. My job is to make the decisions on this type of thing. I will ask for your input and perspective at times, and you’re certainly welcome to ask when there’s something you’d like to see, but ultimately that’s a call I’ll make myself.”

And actually, it’s possible you could do that here too! If you feel you can, do.

Alternately, you can convey that same message without spelling it out so explicitly, simply by making it clear that you aren’t being swayed by whatever weird technique he’s attempting. For example:

Him: “My expectation is that you will give me a hint if you think there may be a change coming up.”
You: “No, that’s not something you should expect. If there is a change coming, your department head will be the first person to talk with you about it.”

Him: “My expectation is that you will change the meeting time.”
You: “No, I’m not going to reschedule this meeting since it involves so many other people and has been on calendars for a while.”

Him: “I’m sure you understand why you need to have this person fired.”
You: “I don’t agree that’s warranted here. This is a small problem, and I will handle it directly with Jane.”

Him: “I know that you will do the right thing and bring this to the Chief Academic Officer.”
You: “No. (The Chief Academic Officer) and I are in agreement that I’ll handle this type of issue. What I will do is…”

Another option is to have a natural reaction to his “my expectation is…” language, meaning that you let yourself seem visibly surprised. For example, when he said his expectation was that you’d change a meeting time, you could say, “I’m surprised you expect that, given how many other people the meeting involves. Can you clarify for me why you’d expect that?” or “That’s landing with me quite strangely! Can you explain what you mean?”

There’s a pretty good chance this if you repeat this a few times, he’ll feel awkward enough that he’ll stop doing it — and ideally may even realize that he can’t push you around.

In a normal work situation — read: not academia — I’d also say to loop your own boss in on what’s going on, given the likelihood of promotion for this guy. Someone above you needs to hear, a minimum, that he has problems respecting women’s authority. But academia is full of weird politics that I don’t have any expertise in, so I can’t tell you if that makes sense to do here or not — but at least consider it as an option.

Read an update to this letter here.

You may also like:
{ 28 comments }

{ 28 comments… read them below }

      1. Three Flowers*

        I adore how she just handed the awkward straight back to him *one time* and won forever.

  3. Observer*

    That was wild. But it’s nice when the trash more or less takes itself out.

    I mean he took himself out of the running for a potentially significant career move because he could not BEAR to work with a woman who has the audacity to expect basic respect? That’s nuts. But a really, really good outcome.

    2. Rock Prof*

      It’s great he has taken himself out of the running. But at least at the schools I’ve been at (US-based), being department chair of an academic is really not a significant career move but often more of role that you cover for a while and then move back into your normal department member role. At my current and former schools, we would just rotate through who was/is chair.

  4. Charlotte Lucas*

    Wow. And I recently chose my words so carefully to point out to my manager that it would have been nice to be told ahead of time that I was expected to present at a big, in-person meeting rather than finding out from… reading the agenda.

  5. Reluctant Mezzo*

    I’ll be glad when I get my email notification again, but that’s probably a server issue too. Good luck, and see you in the funny papers!

  6. I'm just here for the cats!!*

    I remember this letter when it first came out and this guy was such a jerk! I didn’t remember before, but he wanted the bookstore employee fired (!) for a minor mistake. Not only is that wild but he obviously knows nothing. From my experience bookstores and their workers are not employees of the university. It’s usually a 3rd party like Follett. The OP would not have the standing to fire an employee anymore than if it was a non university store. The bookstore is just contracted with the university. Plus it’s HARD to find decent employees for college bookstores. This guy was clueless

  7. hmm m*

    Academia is so weird and tiring. We all know one (or multiple) personalities like this. Sigh.

    3. NursingaWound*

      I was just notified that the chair of my department *in the 1970s* just died after retiring LAST YEAR. He was a nice enough guy but jeez I can’t imagine working there with hopes of moving up. These people never leave.

    4. Seal*

      I inherited a couple of these at my last job. Despite being surrounded by brilliant, highly respected academics and staff members with multiple degrees and years of experience, many of whom were known nationally or internationally as experts in their respective fields, these guys were convinced that they knew better. The only thing they hated more than being managed was being managed by a woman who didn’t acknowledge their inherent superiority; naturally they hated me.

  8. pomme de terre*

    I work in higher ed, but I’ve worked in different industries too, and LOL to the folks here who think they are organizational masterminds when they couldn’t manage their way out of a paper bag. It sounds like this was on the faculty side but there are some staffers like this as well.

    1. knitted feet*

      Yep same, and yep this is way too familiar. Nothing more exhausting than the absolute tool who’s fallen upwards a few levels in higher ed and now thinks he’s come up with a cunning plan.

  9. Alex*

    It’s a good thing I don’t write an advice column, because my advice would be to say back, “Well it is my expectation that you wouldn’t be a complete ass, but I guess we both get to be disappointed today.”

    1. MtnLaurel*

      I may or may not have fantasized at giving this exact comeback during my time in academia.

  11. Zona the Great*

    “Since none of this will be happening, can I expect your resignation by end of day?”

  12. LCH*

    Nice, I’m glad she went with the response I would use (I’d mainly use it out of confusion the first time, I’m sure.) “My expectation is that you would…” “Why?” Whyyyyyyyyyyy.

  13. Guacamole Bob*

    I’m middle management, so I’m familiar with “managing up” in both directions. I can sometimes tell that one of my direct reports is managing up with me in an intentional way, and it’s fine! Often appreciated, even, as it usually means they’re taking ownership of the project and moving it forward while giving me opportunities to participate rather than waiting for my direction and signoff.

    This is not managing up.

    1. Bike Walk Bake Books*

      Same! I’ve thanked my direct reports when I can tell they’re making sure I remember or take care of something we’d discussed a while back that I haven’t gotten to. Fortunately they’re awesome and wouldn’t do any of what this guy pulled.

Comments are closed.